Exordinary the concept of labor unions, including membership levels and also wagesEvaluate disagreements for and also versus labor unionsAnalyze factors for the decline in U.S. union membership

A labor union is an company of employees that negotiates through employers over weras and also working conditions. A labor union seeks to change the balance of power in between employers and employees by requiring employers to deal with employees jointly, fairly than as people. Thus, negotiations between unions and also firms are sometimes dubbed cumulative bargaining.

You are watching: Major reasons employees join unions include all of the following except ________.

The subject of labor unions can be controversial. Supporters of labor unions check out them as the workers’ main line of defense versus initiatives by profit-seeking firms to host down wages and benefits. Critics of labor unions check out them as having actually a tendency to grab as much as they can in the short term, also if it suggests injuring employees in the lengthy run by driving firms right into bankruptcy or by blocking the brand-new modern technologies and also production approaches that lead to economic development. We will certainly begin with some facts around union membership in the United States.

Facts about Union Membership and also Pay

According to the UNITED STATE Bureau of Labor and also Statistics, about 11.1% of all U.S. employees belong to unions. Following are some of the facts offered by the bureau for 2014:

12.0% of U.S. male workers belong to unions; 10.5% of female employees do11.1% of white workers, 13.4 % of babsence employees, and 9.8 % of Hispanic employees belong to unions12.5% of full-time employees and also 6.0% of part-time workers are union members4.2% of workers ages 16–24 belong to unions, as do 14% of employees ages 45-54Occupations in which reasonably high percentperiods of employees belengthy to unions are the federal federal government (26.9% belengthy to a union), state federal government (31.3%), regional federal government (41.7%); transportation and utilities (20.6%); organic sources, construction, and also maintenance (16.3%); and manufacturing, transport, and also material relocating (14.7%)Occupations that have reasonably low percentages of unionized workers are farming workers (1.4%), financial services (1.1%), expert and also company solutions (2.4%), leisure and hospitality (2.7%), and wholesale and retail trade (4.7%)

In summary, the percent of employees belonging to a union is better for men than women; greater for blacks than for whites or Hispanics; higher for the 45–64 age range; and greater among workers in government and manufacturing than employees in agriculture or service-oriented work. Table 2 lists the biggest UNITED STATE labor unions and their membership.

National Education Association (NEA)3.2 million
Service Employees Internationwide Union (SEIU)2.1 million
Amerideserve to Federation of Teachers (AFT)1.5 million
International Brotherhood of Teamsters (IBT)1.4 million
The American Federation of State, County, and also Municipal Workers (AFSCME)1.3 million
United Food and Commercial Workers International Union1.3 million
United Steelworkers1.2 million
Internationwide Union, United Automobile, Aeroarea and also Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW)990,000
International Association of Machinists and Aeroarea Workers720,000
International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW)675,000
Table 2. The Largest Amerideserve to Unions in 2013. (Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics)

In regards to pay, benefits, and hiring, U.S. unions offer a good news/poor news story. The good news for unions and also their members is that their members earn about 20% more than nonunion employees, also after adjusting for components such as years of job-related experience and education and learning level. The poor news for unions is that the share of U.S. employees that belengthy to a labor union has actually been steadily declining for 50 years, as displayed in Figure 1. About one-quarter of all U.S. employees belonged to a union in the mid-1950s, yet only 11.1% of U.S. employees are union members today. If you leave out employees employed by the government (which includes teachers in public schools), only 6.6% of the workers employed by exclusive firms now work for a union.

Figure 1. Percentage of Wage and Salary Workers Who Are Union Members. The share of wage and salary employees that belong to unions rose sharply in the 1930s and also 1940s, however has tailed off given that then to 11.1% of all workers in 2014.

The following area analyzes the better pay union employees get compared the pay prices for nonunion workers. The complying with section analyzes decreasing union membership levels. An oversee of these two problems will allow us to comment on many kind of elements of how unions job-related.

Higher Weras for Union Workers

Why can union employees receive greater pay? What are the boundaries on how much greater pay they have the right to receive? To analyze these inquiries, let’s consider a situation where all firms in an industry should negotiate via a single union, and no firm is enabled to hire nonunion labor. If no labor union existed in this sector, then equilibrium (E) in the labor industry would certainly take place at the intersection of the demand also for labor (D) and also the supply of labor (S) in Figure 2. The union can, however, thrconsumed that, unless firms agree to the wperiods they demand also, the employees will strike. As a result, the labor union manages to achieve, via negotiations through the firms, a union wage of Wu for its members, above what the equilibrium wage would otherwise have been.

Figure 2. Union Wage Negotiations. Without a union, the equilibrium at E would have actually involved the wage We and also the amount of labor Qe. However before, the union is able to usage its bargaining power to raise the wage to Wu. The outcome is an excess supply of labor for union work. That is, a amount of labor offered, Qs is greater than firms’ amount demanded for labor, Qd.

This labor industry instance resembles what a monopoly firm does in selling a product, however in this case a union is a monopoly marketing labor to firms. At the better union wage Wu, the firms in this industry will hire much less labor than they would have actually hired in equilibrium. Furthermore, an excess supply of employees desire union tasks, but firms will not be hiring for such tasks.

From the union suggest of watch, employees who receive better weras are better off. However, notice that the amount of employees (Qd) hired at the union wage Wu is smaller than the amount Qe that would have been hired at the original equilibrium wage. A sensible union need to acknowledge that when it pushes up the wage, it additionally reduces the motivation of firms to hire. This case does not necessarily intend that union employees are fired. Instead, it might be that when union employees relocate on to other jobs or retire, they are not constantly reinserted. Or perhaps once a firm increases production, it increases employment somewhat much less with a higher union wage than it would certainly have done with the reduced equilibrium wage. Or maybe a firm decides to purchase inputs from nonunion producers, rather than developing them with its own highly phelp unionized workers. Or perhaps the firm moves or opens a brand-new facility in a state or country wright here unions are less effective.

From the firm’s allude of view, the key question is whether the better wage of union employees is matched by higher productivity. If so, then the firm can afford to pay the better union wperiods and, indeed, the demand also curve for “unionized” labor can actually transition to the right. This could mitigate the project losses as the equilibrium employment level shifts to the right and also the difference between the equilibrium and the union wperiods will certainly have been lessened. If worker unionization does not rise efficiency, then the greater union wage will certainly reason reduced revenues or losses for the firm.

Union employees could have better productivity than nonunion workers for a variety of reasons. First, higher weras might elicit higher efficiency. 2nd, union workers tend to remain longer at a offered job, a trend that reduces the employer’s prices for training and hiring and also results in employees with more years of endure. Many type of unions additionally offer job training and also apprenticeship programs.

In addition, firms that are faced via union demands for higher wages might pick production approaches that involve even more physical capital and also much less labor, causing enhanced labor efficiency. Table 3 offers an example. Assume that a firm deserve to create a residence exercise cycle through 3 various combicountries of labor and also production devices. Say that labor is paid $16 an hour (consisting of benefits) and also the makers for manufacturing price $200 each. Under these scenarios, the complete cost of producing a house exercise cycle will certainly be lowest if the firm adopts the arrangement of 50 hours of labor and one machine, as the table reflects. Now, suppose that a union negotiates a wage of $20 an hour consisting of benefits. In this situation, it makes no distinction to the firm whether it offers even more hours of labor and also fewer equipments or much less labor and also even more equipments, though it might prefer to use more machines and also to hire fewer union workers. (After all, machines never threaten to strike—but they do not buy the final product or company either.) In the last column of the table, the wage has actually increased to $24 an hour. In this instance, the firm plainly has actually an impetus for utilizing the plan that requires paying for fewer hours of labor and also making use of three machines. If administration responds to union requirements for higher wperiods by investing more in machinery, then union employees can be even more abundant because they are functioning via even more or much better physical funding equipment than the typical nonunion worker. However, the firm will certainly have to hire fewer employees.

Hours of LaborNumber of MachinesCost of Labor + Cost of Machine $16/hourCost of Labor + Cost of Machine $20/hourCost of Labor + Cost of Machine $24/hr
303$480 + $600 = $1,080$600 + $600 = $1,200$720 + $600 = $1,320
402$640 + $400 = $1,040$800 + $400 = $1,200$960 + $400 = $1,360
501$800 + $200 = $1,000$1,000 + $200 = $1,200$1,200 + $200 = $1,400
Table 3. Three Production Choices to Manufacture a Home Exercise Cycle

In some cases, unions have actually discouraged the usage of labor-saving physical funding equipment—out of the reasonable are afraid that new machinery will certainly mitigate the variety of union jobs. For instance, in 2002, the union representing longshoremales who unfill ships and also the firms that run shipping carriers and also port facilities staged a work stoppage that shut down the ports on the western coast of the United States. Two essential problems in the conflict were the desire of the shipping service providers and port operators to usage handheld scanners for record-keeping and also computer-operated cabs for loading and also unloading ships—alters which the union opposed, in addition to overtime pay. President Obama intimidated to usage the Labor Management Relations Act of 1947—typically well-known as the Taft-Hartley Act—wright here a court have the right to impose an 80-day “cooling-off period” in order to enable time for negotiations to proceed without the danger of a job-related stopweb page. Federal mediators were dubbed in, and also the two sides agreed to a deal in February 2015. The ultimate agreement permitted the brand-new modern technologies, yet likewise retained weras, health and wellness, and also pension benefits high for workers. In the previous, presidential usage of the Taft-Hartley Act periodically has actually made labor negotiations more bitter and also argumentative however, in this instance, it appears to have actually smoothed the road to an agreement.

In various other instances, unions have actually verified quite willing to take on new innovations. In one significant instance, during the 1950s and also 1960s, the United Mineemployees union demanded that mining carriers install labor-saving machinery in the mines. The mineworkers’ union realized that over time, the brand-new devices would mitigate the variety of work in the mines, yet the union leaders additionally knew that the mine owners would have to pay higher wages if the workers came to be more abundant, and mechanization was a vital action towards greater productivity.

In reality, in some cases union workers may be even more willing to accept brand-new innovation than nonunion employees, because the union workers think that the union will negotiate to safeguard their tasks and also wages, whereas nonunion workers might be more concerned that the new technology will certainly replace their work. In enhancement, union workers, that generally have actually greater task market suffer and training, are most likely to experience much less and advantage even more than non-union employees from the introduction of new modern technology. Overall, it is difficult to make a definitive case that union employees as a group are constantly either even more or much less welcoming to new modern technology than are nonunion employees.

The Decline in UNITED STATE Union Membership

The propercentage of UNITED STATE workers belonging to unions has actually declined substantially since the beforehand 1950s. Economists have available a variety of feasible explanations:

The shift from manufacturing to organization industriesThe force of globalization and enhanced competition from foreign producersA decreased desire for unions because of the workarea security legislations now in placeU.S. legal setting that provides it reasonably even more difficult for unions to organize employees and also expand also their membership

Let’s discuss each of these four explanations in more information.

A initially possible explanation for the decrease in the share of U.S. workers belonging to unions entails the trends of task development in the production and also service sectors of the economic situation shown in Figure 3. The U.S. economy had around 15 million production jobs in 1960. This full climbed to 19 million by the late 1970s and then decreased to 17 million in 2013. Meanwhile, the variety of jobs in business sectors and in government combined increased from 35 million in 1960 to over 118 million by 2013, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Because over time unions were more powerful in production than in company industries, the expansion in tasks was not happening wright here the unions were. It is exciting to note that numerous of the greatest unions in the country are consisted of of government employees, including the Amerihave the right to Federation of State, County and also Municipal Employees (AFSCME); the Service Employees Internationwide Union; and also the National Education Association. The membership of each of these unions is detailed in Table 2. Outside of federal government employees, but, unions have not had actually excellent success in organizing the company sector.

Figure 3. The Growth of Service Jobs. Jobs in solutions have increased dramatically in the last few years. Jobs in federal government have increased modestly. Jobs in manufacturing have actually not readjusted a lot, although they have actually trfinished down in current years. Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics.

A second explacountry for the decline in the share of unionized employees looks at import competition. Starting in the 1960s, UNITED STATE carequipments and steelmakers faced raising competition from Japanese and European manufacturers. As sales of imported cars and also steel climbed, the variety of tasks in UNITED STATE auto production fell. This market is greatly unionized. Not surprisingly, membership in the United Auto Workers, which was 975,000 in 1985, had actually fallen to about 390,000 by 2015. Import competition not only decreases the employment in sectors where unions were when strong, but additionally decreases the bargaining power of unions in those sectors. However before, as we have viewed, unions that organize public-sector workers, who are not threatened by import competition, have continued to see growth.

A third feasible factor for the decline in the number of union workers is that citizens often call on their elected representatives to pass laws concerning job-related problems, overtime, parental leave, regulation of pensions, and also other problems. Unions available strong political assistance for these regulations aimed at protecting workers however, in an ironic twist, the passage of those regulations then made many kind of employees feel less require for unions.

These first 3 feasible factors for the decline of unions are all rather plausible, however they have actually a common trouble. Many various other arisen economic climates have actually competent equivalent financial and political fads, such as the transition from production to services, globalization, and also enhancing government social benefits and also regulation of the worklocation. Clearly there are social differences in between countries regarding their acceptance of unions in the worklocation. The share of the populace belonging to unions in other countries is incredibly high compared via the share in the USA. Table 4 mirrors the propercent of employees in a variety of the world’s high-income economic situations who belong to unions. The United States is near the bottom, together with France and also Spain. The last column reflects union coverage, identified as including those employees whose weras are identified by a union negotiation also if the workers execute not officially belong to the union. In the United States, union membership is practically similar to union coverage. However before, in many nations, the wperiods of many workers who do not officially belong to a union are still figured out by collective barobtaining in between unions and firms.

CountryUnion Density: Percentage of Workers Belonging to a UnionUnion Coverage: Percentage of Workers Whose Wperiods Are Determined by Union Bargaining
United Kingdom29%35%
United States11.1%12.5%
Table 4. Internationwide Comparisons of Union Membership and also Coverage in 2012. (Source, CIA World Factbook, retrieved from www.cia.gov)

These global distinctions in union membership suggest a fourth reason for the decrease of union membership in the United States: maybe U.S. legislations are much less friendly to the development of unions than such laws in other nations. The cshed connection in between union membership and a friendly legal atmosphere is evident in the background of U.S. unions. The great climb in union membership in the 1930s complied with the passage of the National Labor-Management Relations Act of 1935, which specified that employees had a right to organize unions and also that monitoring had to give them a fair possibility to carry out so. The U.S. government strongly motivated the development of unions throughout the early on 1940s in the belief that unions would help to coordinate the all-out manufacturing efforts needed in the time of World War II. However, after World War II came the passage of the Taft-Hartley Act of 1947, which gave says the power to allow workers to opt out of the union in their workplace if they so preferred. This legislation made the legal climate much less encouraging to those seeking to form unions, and union membership levels shortly began decreasing.

The actions for developing a union differ substantially from nation to country. For instance, the procedures in the United States and also those in Canada are strikingly various. When a team of employees wish to form a union in the United States, they announce this truth and also an election day is collection once the employees at a firm will vote in an enigma ballot on whether to develop a union. Supporters of the union lobby for a “yes” vote, and the administration of the firm lobbies for a “no” vote—often even hiring external consultants for assistance in swaying workers to vote “no.” In Canada, by comparison, a union is formed once a enough proportion of workers (usually around 60%) authorize an main card saying that they desire a union. There is no sepaprice “election date.” The administration of Canadian firms is restricted by regulation in its ability to lobby against the union. In enhancement, though it is illegal to discriminate and also fire employees based on their union task in the USA, the penalties are slight, making this a not so costly means of deterring union task. In short, forming unions is less complicated in Canada—and also in many type of other countries—than in the United States.

See more: What Does Dislocated Worker Mean For Fafsa ? Federal Student Aid

In summary, union membership in the USA is lower than in many type of various other high-revenue nations, a distinction that may be due to different legal atmospheres and social mindsets towards unions.