Lets say I am functioning on a task through 2 various other people and there is some information that I must job-related, so Can I ask choose this:

Can you please tell me "How am I expected to run this script?".

instead of

Can you please tell me "How execute I run this script?".

What I am trying to ask is whether replacing do through supposed to renders the question rude?Due to the fact that generally it is used in a expression favor this:

How am I intended to understand you don"t prefer something



I"m not rather sure why OP is asking, given that he seems to understand the answer anymeans.

You are watching: How am i supposed to know

You don"t generally ask How am I meant to do X? in a real soul of enquiry, because it"s pretty much the straight identical of How execute you expect me to carry out X?. These develops are invariably supplied in hostile/beligerent/uncooperative contexts.

OP"s How do/can I do X? is the "standard" form, but if you want to be a bit even more deferential/polite, you can constantly ask How should I carry out X?


Much depends on the circumstances, on your connection through the various other party and on the tamong voice in which you ask your question. Supposed to can be sassist so as not to offer offence, yet if you are in any doubt about when and also just how to say it, it might be safer to avoid it. I don’t think anyone would certainly object if you put your question as ‘Look, I’m not as well sure about just how I have to run this manuscript. Do you think you might offer me some ideas?’


Thanks for contributing a response to soimg.org Language & Usage Stack Exchange!

Please be certain to answer the question. Provide details and also share your research!

But avoid

Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.Making statements based upon opinion; ago them up through references or individual endure.

See more: What Was Trench Warfare Intended To Accomplish ? Trench Warfare

To learn even more, check out our tips on composing good answers.

Post Your Answer Discard

By clicking “Blog post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of organization, privacy policy and also cookie plan

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other concerns tagged politeness meaning or ask your very own question.


site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exadjust Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. rev2021.12.22.41046

Your privacy

By clicking “Accept all cookies”, you agree Stack Exchange deserve to save cookies on your device and also discshed indevelopment in accordance through our Cookie Policy.